By Kevin Henkes
This coming of age book could be an incredible story, but it falls a little flat for me. I think it tries to encompass too much. It tries to cope with death of a classmate, first love, secret passion of writing a demanding sibling, parental discord and a lasting relationship with a grandparent. If one of the conflicts would be eliminated it would be a stronger read.
Martha's summer is going pretty well until she finds out that a classmate, Olive, has died in a tragic accident. Even though they were never truly friends, Martha gets a surprise visit from Olive's Mom. Martha receives a slip of paper from Olive's journal. Martha gets a inside look into Olive's shy life. Olive shares her desire to write and a wish to visit the ocean. Of course, Martha spends part of every summer at her Grandmothers on the east coast. Olive dwells on how to find closure for her dead classmate, has a romantic kiss, almost drowns before she safely returns home. Unfortunately, since the main conflict was diluted there was no strong climax and no resolution that left the reader wanting more. I am going to give this book a 3 out of 5, it was sufficient but I found it lacking. This book is appropriate for readers 5th grade through 7th grade.
Links
Author Kevin Henkes
Dealing with the death of a classmate
Guide on how to become a writer
No comments:
Post a Comment